The following movies have qualified for the comedy bracket:
| Airplane |
| American Pie |
| Anchorman |
| Back to the Future |
| Big Lebowski |
| Bill and Ted’s Excellent Adventure |
| Billy Madison |
| Blazing Saddles |
| Caddyshack |
| Christmas Story |
| Christmas Vacation |
| Dude Where’s My Car |
| Dumb and Dumber |
| Flash Gordon |
| Grumpy Old Men |
| Half-Baked |
| Happy Gilmore |
| History of the World, Part 1 |
| My Cousin Vinny |
| Napolean Dynamite |
| Office Space |
| Out Cold |
| Porky’s |
| Role Models |
| South Park |
| Stepbrothers |
| Super Troopers |
| Superbad |
| Swingers |
| Talledega Nights |
| The Hangover |
| The Other Guys |
| This is Spinal Tap |
| Tommy Boy |
| Vacation |
| Wayne’s World |
| Wedding Crashers |
| What about Bob? |
| Zoolander |
The following is a list of nominations that have yet to make the comedy bracket, along with the current number of votes:
| Spaceballs | 3 |
| Groundhog Day | 3 |
| Harold and Kumar | 2 |
| The New Guy | 2 |
| Road Trip | 2 |
| White Chicks | 2 |
| Airheads | 1 |
| Ace Ventura | 1 |
| Amazon Women on the Moon | 1 |
| Austin Powers | 1 |
| Beavis and Butthead | 1 |
| Beerfest | 1 |
| Best in Show | 1 |
| Beverly Hills Cop | 1 |
| Bio-Dome | 1 |
| Big Momma’s House | 1 |
| Blankman | 1 |
| Burn After Reading | 1 |
| Bushwacked | 1 |
| Clerks 2 | 1 |
| Dead Men on Campus | 1 |
| Deuce Bigalow | 1 |
| Dodgeball | 1 |
| Ernest Goes to Camp | 1 |
| Family Guy | 1 |
| Ferris Bueller’s Day Off | 1 |
| Freaked | 1 |
| Funny Farm | 1 |
| Ghostbusters | 1 |
| The Great Outdoors | 1 |
| Horrible Bosses | 1 |
| Kingpin | 1 |
| Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back | 1 |
| Major League | 1 |
| McHale’s Navy | 1 |
| Mousehunt | 1 |
| Nutty Professor | 1 |
| Paul Blart: Mall Cop | 1 |
| Princess Bride | 1 |
| O, Brother Where art Thou? | 1 |
| Old School | 1 |
| The Odd Couple | 1 |
| Ready 2 Rumble | 1 |
| Real Men | 1 |
| Rubber | 1 |
| Shaun of the Dead | 1 |
| So I Married an axe murderer | 1 |
| The Stoned Age | 1 |
| Student Bodies | 1 |
| Trading Places | 1 |
| UHF | 1 |
| Uncle Buck | 1 |
| Van Wilder | 1 |
| Waiting | 1 |
| Waterboy | 1 |
| Young Frankenstein | 1 |
| Zombieland | 1 |
